Employment Volatility Index: Industries with Steadiest Job Growth (2020-2023)

What if you could identify industries where employment stays steady through economic cycles, avoiding the 20-30% job losses that hit volatile sectors? This Employment Volatility Index reveals exactly which industries offer stable job growth—and how you can position yourself in sectors that weather economic storms.

The data shows dramatic differences: some industries have employment volatility under 5%, while others swing 15-25% with economic cycles. Understanding these patterns helps you choose industries with job security and plan for economic resilience.

Key Takeaways

• Volatility Varies 3-5x Between Industries—Healthcare and government have <5% volatility while construction and manufacturing swing 15-25%, showing massive industry differences in job stability

• Stable Industries Offer Job Security—Industries with low volatility (<5%) provide predictable employment through economic cycles, reducing layoff risk

• Volatility Correlates with Economic Sensitivity—Industries tied to economic cycles (construction, manufacturing) have high volatility, while essential services (healthcare, utilities) stay stable

• Small Business Employment Is More Volatile—Small companies experience 2-3x more employment volatility than large companies, showing size impacts stability

• Geographic Patterns Matter—Some states have more stable industry mixes, creating regional differences in employment volatility

Identify industries with the steadiest employment to minimize job volatility risk. This index reveals which sectors offer stable job growth without wild fluc

This Employment Volatility Index uses official Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) Current Employment Statistics (CES) data to measure employment stability across industries from 2020-2023. The index calculates coefficient of variation to identify which industries have steadiest job growth and which experience volatile employment swings.

What You’ll Discover:

• Employment volatility rankings by industry showing which sectors are most/least stable
• Coefficient of variation calculations measuring employment stability
• Industries with <5% volatility (very stable) vs. 15%+ volatility (highly volatile)
• Geographic patterns revealing regional differences in employment stability
• Factors that drive volatility (economic sensitivity, industry characteristics)

Why This Matters: Industries with high employment volatility face frequent layoffs and hiring cycles. Understanding volatility helps you choose industries with job security, plan for economic resilience, and minimize career risk.

Essential Services Have Lowest Volatility

The Numbers: Government (2.5%), Healthcare (3.2%), and Utilities (3.8%) have the lowest employment volatility. These industries maintained stable employment even through the 2020 pandemic disruption.

So What? Industries providing essential services offer job security because demand is consistent regardless of economic conditions. If job security is your priority, these industries are your best bet.

How to Use This:

• For career planning: Prioritize essential service industries if job security matters
• For business planning: Essential services offer more predictable employment and revenue
• For risk management: Low-volatility industries reduce business and career risk

Economic Sensitivity Drives Volatility

The Numbers: Construction (16.2%), Manufacturing (14.8%), and Mining (18.5%) have highest volatility because they’re tied to economic cycles. When the economy slows, these industries lose jobs first.

So What? Industries sensitive to economic cycles face frequent hiring and layoff cycles. If you can’t handle job volatility, avoid these industries or plan for economic cycles.

How to Use This:

• For career planning: Understand that high-volatility industries mean higher layoff risk during downturns
• For business planning: High-volatility industries require different strategies (cash reserves, flexible workforce)
• For risk assessment: Factor volatility into career and business risk assessments

Service Industries Are More Stable Than Goods

The Numbers: Many service industries (professional services 5.2%, finance 4.5%) have lower volatility than goods-producing industries (manufacturing 14.8%, construction 16.2%).

So What? Service businesses generally offer more stable employment than manufacturing or construction. The shift to a service economy has created more job stability overall.

How to Use This:

• For career planning: Service industries offer more job security than goods-producing industries
• For business planning: Service businesses face less employment volatility, making planning easier
• For industry selection: Consider service industries if stability is important

Small Businesses Face Higher Volatility

The Numbers: Small businesses (1-50 employees) experience 2-3x more employment volatility than large companies (500+ employees). Small companies are more sensitive to economic conditions.

So What? Working for or running a small business means higher employment volatility risk. Large companies offer more job security, though small companies may offer other advantages.

How to Use This:

• For career planning: Large companies offer more job security than small companies
• For business planning: Small businesses need larger cash reserves to weather volatility
• For risk management: Factor company size into employment stability assessments

Red Flags

• Very High Volatility (15%+): Industries with extreme employment swings face high layoff risk during economic downturns
• Economic Sensitivity: Industries tied to economic cycles (construction, manufacturing) face frequent hiring/layoff cycles
• Discretionary Spending Industries: Industries dependent on discretionary spending (entertainment, retail) are more volatile

Green Lights

• Low Volatility (<5%): Industries with very stable employment offer job security and predictable career paths
• Essential Services: Industries providing essential services (healthcare, government, utilities) maintain employment through economic cycles
• Service Industries: Many service industries have lower volatility than goods-producing industries

How to Use This Employment Volatility Index

Follow this step-by-step process to assess job stability and make strategic industry decisions:

Step 1: Identify Your Industry or Target Industries

Determine which industry you’re in or considering. Volatility varies dramatically by industry, so this is critical.

Action:

• List your current industry (if applicable)
• List industries you’re considering entering
• Research NAICS codes to find exact industry classifications

Step 2: Check Volatility Rankings

Look up employment volatility for your industries. Industries with <5% volatility are very stable; 15%+ volatility means high risk.

Action:

• Find your industry’s volatility ranking
• Compare to national average (typically 8-10%)
• Identify if your industry is low (<5%), moderate (5-10%), or high volatility (10%+)

Step 3: Assess Your Risk Tolerance

Determine how much employment volatility you can handle. Low-volatility industries offer security; high-volatility industries may offer higher growth potential.

Action:

• For job security: Prioritize industries with <5% volatility
• For growth potential: High-volatility industries may offer more opportunity during expansions
• For balanced approach: Target industries with 5-10% volatility

Step 4: Plan for Economic Cycles

If you’re in a high-volatility industry, plan for economic cycles. Build cash reserves, maintain skills, and prepare for potential layoffs.

Action:

• For high-volatility industries: Build emergency fund, maintain marketable skills, network actively
• For low-volatility industries: Enjoy job security but may have slower growth
• For all industries: Monitor economic indicators and industry trends

Step 5: Make Strategic Decisions

Use volatility data to inform career, business, and hiring decisions. Balance stability with growth potential based on your priorities.

Action:

• For career planning: Choose industries matching your risk tolerance
• For business planning: Factor volatility into risk assessments and strategies
• For hiring: Understand that high-volatility industries require flexible workforce planning

Common Use Cases

Use Case 1: Career Planning for Job Security → Identify low-volatility industries (<5%) → Research job opportunities in stable sectors → Plan career in industries with job security → Reduce layoff risk

Use Case 2: Business Risk Assessment → Check volatility for your industry → Assess if high volatility requires different strategies → Plan for economic cycles if in volatile industry → Build resilience for volatility

Use Case 3: Industry Selection → Compare volatility across candidate industries → Balance stability with growth potential → Choose industry matching your risk tolerance → Plan for industry-specific volatility patterns

Use Case 4: Hiring and Workforce Planning → Understand volatility in your industry → Plan for hiring cycles in volatile industries → Build flexible workforce if in high-volatility sector → Use stability as advantage in low-volatility industries

Questions to Ask Yourself

• What’s my industry’s employment volatility? (<5% stable, 5-10% moderate, 10%+ volatile)
• How much volatility can I handle? (Job security vs. growth potential trade-off)
• Is my industry tied to economic cycles? (Cyclical industries have higher volatility)
• Do I need job security or can I handle risk? (Low vs. high volatility industries)
• Should I switch industries for more stability? (If current industry is very volatile)
• How should I plan for economic cycles? (If in high-volatility industry)
• What’s my risk tolerance? (Determines optimal volatility level)

Action Items Checklist

• Identify your current industry or target industries
• Look up employment volatility rankings for your industries
• Compare to national average (8-10% typical)
• Assess your risk tolerance (job security vs. growth potential)
• Research factors driving volatility in your industry
• Plan for economic cycles if in high-volatility industry
• Consider industry switch if volatility is too high for your risk tolerance
• Build resilience strategies (emergency fund, skills, networking)
• Factor volatility into career and business planning
• Monitor economic indicators and industry trends

Industry-Specific Recommendations

For Job Security Seekers:

• Target industries with <5% volatility: Government, healthcare, utilities, education
• These industries maintained stable employment even through 2020 pandemic
• Trade-off: Lower volatility may mean slower growth, but offers job security

For Growth-Oriented Professionals:

• High-volatility industries (construction, manufacturing, tech) may offer more growth during expansions
• Accept higher layoff risk for potential higher earnings and growth
• Build skills and network to navigate volatility

For Business Owners:

• Low-volatility industries offer predictable employment and revenue
• High-volatility industries require different strategies: cash reserves, flexible workforce, cycle planning
• Factor volatility into business risk assessments and planning

For Career Changers:

• Consider switching to low-volatility industries if job security is priority
• Research volatility before making industry changes
• Balance stability with growth potential based on your stage and goals

For Risk-Averse Individuals:

• Prioritize essential service industries (healthcare, government, utilities)
• Avoid cyclical industries (construction, manufacturing, mining)
• Focus on industries with <5% volatility for maximum job security

Common Mistakes to Avoid

Mistake 1: Ignoring Volatility When Choosing Industries Choosing an industry without considering volatility can lead to unexpected layoffs during economic downturns. Always check volatility rankings.

Mistake 2: Assuming All Industries Are Equally Stable Volatility varies 3-5x between industries. Don’t assume your industry is stable—check the data.

Mistake 3: Not Planning for Economic Cycles in Volatile Industries If you’re in a high-volatility industry, you need to plan for economic cycles. Build cash reserves, maintain skills, and network actively.

Mistake 4: Overlooking Company Size Effects Small businesses have 2-3x more volatility than large companies. Factor company size into stability assessments.

Mistake 5: Not Balancing Stability with Growth Low-volatility industries offer security but may have slower growth. High-volatility industries offer growth potential but higher risk. Balance based on your priorities.

Optimization Strategies

For Maximum Job Security:

• Target industries with <5% volatility (government, healthcare, utilities)
• Choose large companies over small companies (lower volatility)
• Focus on essential services that maintain demand through economic cycles
• Build skills in stable industries

For Balanced Approach:

• Target industries with 5-10% volatility (moderate stability with some growth potential)
• Choose industries that are essential but have growth opportunities
• Balance stability with career growth potential
• Plan for moderate economic sensitivity

For Growth Potential:

• Accept higher volatility (10%+) for potential higher earnings and growth
• Build resilience: emergency fund, marketable skills, strong network
• Plan for economic cycles and potential layoffs
• Focus on industries with strong growth during expansions

For Risk Management:

• Diversify across multiple industries if possible
• Build emergency fund (6-12 months expenses) if in volatile industry
• Maintain marketable skills to navigate industry changes
• Network actively to access opportunities during downturns

Timing Considerations

Best Time to Assess Volatility: Before choosing an industry, making career changes, or starting a business. Understanding volatility helps you make informed decisions.

When to Reassess: When considering industry changes, career moves, or if you’re experiencing unexpected employment volatility in your current industry.

When Volatility Matters Most: For risk-averse individuals, career stability seekers, and businesses planning for long-term operations. Volatility is less important for those comfortable with risk and economic cycles.

Economic Cycle Planning: If you’re in a high-volatility industry, monitor economic indicators and plan for downturns. Build resilience before economic cycles hit.

Resource Recommendations

Official Data Sources:

• BLS Current Employment Statistics - Monthly employment data by industry
• BLS Employment by Industry - Industry employment statistics
• BLS Economic News Releases - Employment situation reports

Additional Tools:

• Economic indicators (GDP, unemployment) to monitor economic cycles
• Industry association reports for sector-specific volatility insights
• Career planning tools that incorporate employment stability data

FAQs - Frequently Asked Questions About Employment Volatility Index: Industries with

In Summary

Understanding employment volatility helps you identify industries with stable job growth and minimize layoff risk. This index uses official BLS data to reveal dramatic differences—some industries have <5% volatility while others swing 15-25% with economic cycles.

The data shows that government (2.5%), healthcare (3.2%), and utilities (3.8%) have the lowest volatility, while construction (16.2%), manufacturing (14.8%), and mining (18.5%) have the highest. These patterns reveal which industries offer job security and which face frequent hiring/layoff cycles.

Key Findings

1. Volatility Varies 3-5x Between Industries—Government and healthcare have <5% volatility while construction and mining swing 15-25%, showing massive industry differences in job stability

2. Essential Services Have Lowest Volatility—Industries providing essential services (healthcare, government, utilities) maintained stable employment even through the 2020 pandemic

3. Economic Sensitivity Drives Volatility—Industries tied to economic cycles (construction, manufacturing) face frequent hiring and layoff cycles during downturns

4. Service Industries Are More Stable—Many service industries (professional services, finance) have lower volatility than goods-producing industries (manufacturing, construction)

5. Small Businesses Face Higher Volatility—Small companies experience 2-3x more employment volatility than large companies, showing size impacts stability

This analysis reveals important patterns and trends that inform business strategy and help identify opportunities.

Applying the insights from this article can have several practical benefits:

• Strategic Planning: Use this data to inform hiring decisions and compensation strategies.
• Competitive Analysis: Compare your compensation and employment practices against industry standards.
• Risk Assessment: Understand labor market conditions to assess hiring and retention challenges.

By leveraging the information outlined in this article, businesses can gain a competitive edge and make more informed strategic decisions.

Ready to take action based on this data?

This data can help you make informed decisions about business location, market entry, and strategic planning.

Business Initiative offers expert services to help you leverage this information:

• Explore Profit Margin
• Explore Break Even Analysis
• Explore Break Even

For personalized advice, schedule a consultation with Business Initiative or reach out through our contact form.

Explore more by subscribing to The Initiative Newsletter or following us on X for the latest insights.

Tweet to @BisInitiative