Payroll Efficiency Analyzer: Compensation per Employee by Industry (2022)

What if you could see that California’s professional services sector pays $131,900 per employee while Wyoming pays $72,700—revealing exactly where compensation efficiency is highest? This Payroll Efficiency Analyzer reveals compensation per employee by industry—and how you can position yourself in markets with the highest wage efficiency.

The data shows dramatic differences: professional services (NAICS 54) payroll per employee ranges from $131,900 in California to $72,700 in Wyoming—a 1.8x difference. This isn’t just about geography—it’s about understanding payroll efficiency, compensation efficiency, and wage efficiency that directly impact your competitive strategy and location decisions.

Key Takeaways

• Payroll efficiency varies dramatically by location—Professional services payroll per employee ranges from $144,600 in Massachusetts to $72,700 in Wyoming (2.0x difference), revealing clear compensation efficiency patterns
• High payroll efficiency indicates competitive compensation—Markets with higher payroll efficiency ($120,000+ per employee) indicate strong compensation efficiency with competitive wage levels
• Location strategy must account for payroll efficiency—Choosing markets with high payroll efficiency provides access to competitive compensation and wage efficiency
• High-efficiency markets offer compensation benefits—Markets with very high payroll efficiency ($120,000+ per employee) offer strong compensation efficiency with competitive wage levels
• Balanced approach often offers best opportunity—Markets with high payroll efficiency ($100,000-$120,000 per employee) and moderate cost of living offer competitive compensation with manageable costs

Analyze payroll efficiency to see compensation per employee by industry. This analysis reve

This analysis examines County Business Patterns (CBP) data from the U.S. Census Bureau to calculate payroll efficiency—compensation per employee by industry and location, revealing where compensation efficiency is highest and which industries show strong wage efficiency. You’ll discover which states have the highest payroll per employee, how compensation efficiency varies by industry, and where opportunities exist for businesses in high-efficiency markets.

What You’ll Discover:

• State rankings by payroll efficiency (compensation per employee)
• Industry-specific payroll efficiency patterns revealing compensation efficiency by location
• Location-specific efficiency indicators impacting competitive strategy
• Payroll efficiency analysis by industry and location
• Compensation efficiency indicators for strategic business decisions

Why This Matters: Understanding payroll efficiency helps you identify markets with high compensation efficiency, assess competitive wage levels, and make strategic location decisions. Markets with higher payroll efficiency offer competitive compensation that supports business growth.

Payroll Efficiency Varies Dramatically by Location

The Numbers: Professional services payroll per employee ranges from $144,600 in Massachusetts to $72,700 in Wyoming—a 2.0x difference. This means Massachusetts has 2.0x higher payroll efficiency than Wyoming, indicating very different compensation efficiency patterns.

So What? Different locations show dramatically different payroll efficiency, indicating vastly different compensation efficiency and competitive wage levels. Understanding these patterns helps you identify where compensation efficiency is strongest and where competitive compensation exists.

How to Use This: If you’re seeking high compensation efficiency, markets with very high payroll efficiency ($120,000+ per employee) like Massachusetts ($144,600), California ($131,900), and New York ($120,800) indicate very high payroll efficiency. Target these markets for access to competitive compensation and wage efficiency.

High Payroll Efficiency Indicates Competitive Compensation

The Numbers: States like Massachusetts ($144,600 per employee), California ($131,900), and New York ($120,800) have the highest professional services payroll efficiency, indicating strong compensation efficiency and competitive wage levels.

So What? Payroll efficiency indicates compensation efficiency. Markets with higher payroll efficiency typically have more competitive compensation structures, wage efficiency, and competitive advantages. These markets offer better access to competitive compensation than lower-efficiency markets.

How to Use This: Target markets where your industry has very high payroll efficiency ($120,000+ per employee) for access to competitive compensation. These markets offer compensation efficiency, wage efficiency, and competitive advantages that lower-efficiency markets may not provide.

Location Strategy Must Account for Payroll Efficiency

The Numbers: The difference between the highest-efficiency state (Massachusetts, $144,600 per employee) and lower-efficiency states (Wyoming, $72,700) is 2.0x, meaning dramatically different compensation efficiency and competitive wage levels.

So What? Payroll efficiency directly impacts your competitive position. Markets with high payroll efficiency offer competitive compensation and wage efficiency. Your location choice should prioritize markets with high payroll efficiency for your industry.

How to Use This: For businesses requiring competitive compensation, target markets with very high payroll efficiency ($120,000+ per employee) for your industry. These markets offer compensation efficiency, wage efficiency, and competitive advantages.

Red Flags

• Very Low Payroll Efficiency (<$80,000 per employee): May indicate limited compensation efficiency and lack of competitive compensation
• Efficiency-Cost Mismatch: Markets with high payroll efficiency but also very high cost of living may create challenging cost dynamics
• Declining Payroll Efficiency: Markets where payroll efficiency is decreasing may signal declining compensation efficiency

Green Lights

• Very High Payroll Efficiency ($120,000+ per employee): Indicates strong compensation efficiency with competitive wage levels and compensation structures
• High Efficiency with Growing Trends: Markets with high payroll efficiency and growing trends signal expanding compensation efficiency
• Consistent High Efficiency: Markets with consistently high payroll efficiency offer stable compensation efficiency
• Diverse High-Efficiency Industries: Markets with high payroll efficiency across multiple industries offer stability and multiple compensation efficiency sources

How to Use This Data

Follow this step-by-step process to identify payroll efficiency and make data-driven location decisions:

Step 1: Identify High-Efficiency Markets for Your Industry

Compare payroll efficiency (compensation per employee) across states for your industry (NAICS code):

• State-level: Get broad payroll efficiency identification
• Industry-specific: Use NAICS-filtered data for your specific industry
• Efficiency Ranking: Rank states by payroll efficiency to identify highest-efficiency markets

Action: Create a spreadsheet with all 50 states. List payroll efficiency (compensation per employee) for your industry in each. Rank by efficiency to identify highest-efficiency markets (strong compensation efficiency).

Step 2: Assess Payroll Efficiency Benefits

High payroll efficiency indicates strong compensation efficiency and competitive wage levels:

• Compensation Efficiency: Access to competitive compensation and wage efficiency
• Competitive Compensation: Competitive advantages from high payroll efficiency
• Market Competitiveness: Strong economies with competitive compensation structures

Action: For each high-efficiency market, assess payroll efficiency benefits. Identify markets with compensation efficiency, wage efficiency, and competitive advantages.

Step 3: Evaluate Payroll Efficiency vs. Cost of Living

Balance payroll efficiency benefits with cost of living:

• High Efficiency, High Cost: May offer competitive compensation but also high cost of living
• High Efficiency, Moderate Cost: Offers best balance of competitive compensation and manageable costs
• Moderate Efficiency, Low Cost: May offer some competitive compensation with lower costs

Action: For each high-efficiency market, evaluate payroll efficiency vs. cost of living. Choose markets that offer competitive compensation with manageable costs.

Step 4: Choose Your Payroll Efficiency Location

Select markets with high payroll efficiency that match your business needs.

Action: Create a decision matrix scoring each location on: payroll efficiency (40%), compensation efficiency (30%), and cost of living (30%). Choose the location with highest score.

Step 5: Make Your Location Decision

Combine payroll efficiency analysis with other factors (business climate, market size) to choose your location.

Action: Create a final decision matrix scoring each location on: payroll efficiency (30%), compensation efficiency (30%), business climate (20%), and market size (20%).

Common Use Cases

Scenario 1: Seeking High Compensation Efficiency → Focus on markets with very high payroll efficiency ($120,000+ per employee). These markets offer strong compensation efficiency with competitive wage levels and compensation structures.

Scenario 2: Balanced Efficiency and Cost → Target markets with high payroll efficiency ($100,000-$120,000 per employee) and moderate cost of living. These markets offer competitive compensation with manageable costs.

Scenario 3: Emerging Efficiency Opportunity → Consider markets with moderate payroll efficiency ($80,000-$100,000 per employee) but growing trends. These markets may offer emerging compensation efficiency with lower costs.

Scenario 4: Risk-Averse Strategy → Focus on markets with moderate-to-high payroll efficiency ($100,000-$120,000 per employee) that offer proven compensation efficiency with stable costs.

Questions to Ask Yourself

• How important is compensation efficiency vs. cost of living for my business?
• Do I need very high payroll efficiency ($120,000+ per employee) or is moderate efficiency ($80,000-$100,000) sufficient?
• What payroll efficiency benefits do I need—compensation efficiency, wage efficiency, or competitive compensation?
• Am I entering a validated high-efficiency market or an emerging one?

Action Items Checklist

• Identify high-efficiency markets for your industry by ranking states by payroll efficiency (compensation per employee)
• Assess payroll efficiency benefits (compensation efficiency, wage efficiency) in high-efficiency markets
• Evaluate payroll efficiency vs. cost of living for each candidate market
• Research payroll efficiency dynamics and competitive compensation in high-efficiency markets
• Compare payroll efficiency benefits with business climate and market size
• Create a decision matrix scoring each location on payroll efficiency, compensation efficiency, and cost of living
• Consult with Business Initiative for payroll efficiency analysis and location strategy guidance

Step 4: Take action. Use the insights to make better decisions.

Industry-Specific Recommendations

Professional Services (NAICS 54): Target markets with very high payroll efficiency ($120,000+ per employee) like Massachusetts ($144,600), California ($131,900), and New York ($120,800). Professional services benefit from high payroll efficiency with strong compensation efficiency.

Technology Services (NAICS 51): Focus on markets with high payroll efficiency in tech hubs. Technology businesses benefit from high payroll efficiency with tech compensation efficiency.

Financial Services (NAICS 52): Look for markets with very high payroll efficiency ($120,000+ per employee) for financial services. Financial services businesses benefit from high payroll efficiency with financial compensation efficiency.

Health Care (NAICS 62): Consider markets with high payroll efficiency ($100,000-$120,000 per employee) for health care. Health care businesses benefit from payroll efficiency with health care compensation efficiency.

Manufacturing (NAICS 31-33): Prioritize markets with moderate-to-high payroll efficiency for manufacturing. Manufacturing businesses benefit from payroll efficiency with manufacturing compensation efficiency.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

Mistake 1: Using Only Payroll Efficiency Without Cost of Living Context Payroll efficiency shows compensation efficiency but doesn’t reveal cost of living, purchasing power, or competitive dynamics. Always consider both efficiency and cost of living when assessing location opportunities.

Mistake 2: Ignoring Cost of Living in High-Efficiency Markets High payroll efficiency may indicate strong compensation efficiency but also high cost of living. Don’t ignore cost of living—high-efficiency markets may have high costs that offset compensation efficiency benefits.

Mistake 3: Not Considering Industry-Specific Efficiency Overall payroll efficiency doesn’t reflect your industry’s specific efficiency patterns. Always use NAICS-filtered data for your specific industry to assess industry-specific payroll efficiency.

Mistake 4: Overlooking Market Dynamics Payroll efficiency shows compensation efficiency but doesn’t reveal market dynamics, competitive positioning, or business model fit. Don’t overlook market dynamics—they impact business viability.

Mistake 5: Not Validating with Market Research Payroll efficiency data shows patterns but doesn’t reveal market dynamics, competitive positioning, or compensation structure quality. Always validate with market research and local analysis.

Optimization Strategies

For Maximum Compensation Efficiency Benefits: Target markets with very high payroll efficiency ($120,000+ per employee) that offer strong compensation efficiency with competitive wage levels and compensation structures.

For Balanced Approach: Focus on markets with high payroll efficiency ($100,000-$120,000 per employee) that offer competitive compensation with manageable cost of living.

For Emerging Efficiency Opportunity: Consider markets with moderate payroll efficiency ($80,000-$100,000 per employee) but growing trends that may offer emerging compensation efficiency with lower costs.

For Risk-Averse Strategy: Prioritize markets with moderate-to-high payroll efficiency ($100,000-$120,000 per employee) that offer proven compensation efficiency with stable costs.

Timing Considerations

Best Time to Enter High-Efficiency Markets: When you have resources ready and competitive positioning complete. High-efficiency markets reward businesses that can leverage compensation efficiency and competitive compensation.

Best Time to Enter Emerging Efficiency Markets: When payroll efficiency is growing, indicating expanding compensation efficiency. Emerging efficiency markets offer compensation efficiency with lower costs but require careful market validation.

When to Reassess: Review payroll efficiency data annually when new CBP releases become available. Market positions change, and what was high-efficiency 2-3 years ago may not be today.

Resource Recommendations

For Payroll Efficiency Analysis:

• Census Bureau County Business Patterns (official CBP data source)
• NAICS code lookup tools (identify your industry classification)
• Cost of living indices (assess purchasing power)
• State economic development websites (local payroll efficiency insights)

For Location Support:

• Business Initiative location strategy services
• Local chamber of commerce (county-level payroll efficiency information)
• State Secretary of State websites (business registration requirements)

For Payroll Efficiency Research:

• Combine CBP payroll and employment data to calculate payroll efficiency
• Research local payroll efficiency dynamics and competitive compensation

• Consult with Business Initiative for personalized payroll efficiency analysis and location guidance

• Consider your specific situation: What works for others might not work for you. You can make mistakes by copying without thinking.

FAQs - Frequently Asked Questions About Payroll Efficiency Analyzer: Compensation per

In Summary

Our comprehensive exploration of payroll efficiency analysis (2022) has revealed critical insights into compensation efficiency, competitive wage levels, and location opportunities that can inform strategic business decisions.

Key Findings:

• Payroll efficiency varies dramatically by location—professional services payroll per employee ranges from $144,600 in Massachusetts to $72,700 in Wyoming (2.0x difference)
• High payroll efficiency indicates competitive compensation—markets with higher payroll efficiency ($120,000+ per employee) indicate strong compensation efficiency with competitive wage levels
• Location strategy must account for payroll efficiency—choosing markets with high payroll efficiency provides access to competitive compensation and wage efficiency
• High-efficiency markets offer compensation benefits—markets with very high payroll efficiency ($120,000+ per employee) offer strong compensation efficiency with competitive wage levels
• Balanced approach often offers best opportunity—markets with high payroll efficiency ($100,000-$120,000 per employee) and moderate cost of living offer competitive compensation with manageable costs

What This Means for Your Business: Understanding payroll efficiency helps you identify markets with high compensation efficiency, assess competitive wage levels, and make strategic location decisions. Markets with higher payroll efficiency offer competitive compensation that supports business growth. The best approach balances payroll efficiency (compensation efficiency) with cost of living and business climate.

Practical Applications:

• Location Strategy: Use payroll efficiency data to identify markets where your industry has very high payroll efficiency ($120,000+ per employee) for access to competitive compensation
• Market Analysis: Compare payroll efficiency across locations to understand compensation efficiency and competitive wage levels
• Competitive Positioning: Target markets with high payroll efficiency for access to compensation efficiency, wage efficiency, and competitive advantages
• Strategic Planning: Prioritize markets with very high payroll efficiency ($120,000+ per employee) for maximum compensation efficiency benefits and competitive compensation

Next Steps:

1. Identify high-efficiency markets for your industry by ranking states by payroll efficiency (compensation per employee)
2. Assess payroll efficiency benefits (compensation efficiency, wage efficiency) in high-efficiency markets
3. Evaluate payroll efficiency vs. cost of living for each candidate market
4. Compare payroll efficiency benefits with business climate and market size
5. Consult with Business Initiative for payroll efficiency analysis and location strategy guidance

Business Initiative offers expert services to help you leverage this information:

• Explore Profit Margin
• Explore Break Even Analysis
• Explore Break Even

For personalized advice, schedule a consultation with Business Initiative or reach out through our contact form.

Explore more by subscribing to The Initiative Newsletter or following us on X for the latest insights.

Tweet to @BisInitiative