Pricing Confidence for Founders: A Step-by-Step Method to Choose and Test Prices

You need to set a price, but you don’t know where to start. Should you charge what competitors charge? Should you base it on your costs? Should you guess and hope for the best? This uncertainty paralyzes many founders, causing them to delay pricing decisions or choose prices that don’t reflect the true value of what they’re offering.

Pricing uncertainty creates a cascade of problems. If you price too low, you leave money on the table and struggle to grow. If you price too high, you lose customers before they even understand your value. If you avoid setting prices altogether, you can’t make sales. The challenge is that pricing feels like a one-time decision with permanent consequences, but it doesn’t have to be.

This guide provides a structured, step-by-step method for choosing initial prices and testing them systematically.

We’ll walk through a proven framework that helps you set prices with confidence, then shows you how to test and refine those prices based on real customer data. By the end, you’ll have a repeatable process for pricing decisions that removes guesswork and builds confidence.

Why Pricing Confidence Matters

Pricing uncertainty creates hesitation that costs you money and momentum. When you’re not confident in your prices, you second-guess every sales conversation, hesitate to raise prices when costs increase, and miss opportunities to optimize profitability. This lack of confidence shows in how you present prices to customers, and it can undermine your entire value proposition.

Confident pricing, on the other hand, enables better business decisions. When you know your prices are based on solid reasoning and real data, you can present them with conviction, negotiate from a position of strength, and make adjustments based on evidence rather than fear. This confidence improves your sales conversations, strengthens your brand positioning, and ultimately increases your profitability.

The reality: Most founders who struggle with pricing don’t have a systematic approach. They set prices once, hope they’re right, and then avoid revisiting them even when circumstances change. A structured method removes this uncertainty and gives you a process you can trust.

Step One: Calculate Your Baseline

Before you can set a price with confidence, you need to know your costs. This baseline price ensures you don’t lose money on every sale, and it provides a floor below which you should never go. Many founders skip this step and end up pricing below their costs without realizing it.

Calculate Cost-Based Pricing

Start with your numbers:

• Use our Price Markup Calculator to determine your cost-based pricing
• Enter your product or service costs, including direct costs and a portion of overhead
• Set a target profit margin that ensures sustainability
• Calculate the minimum price you need to charge to cover costs and achieve your margin goal

Why this matters: Cost-based pricing gives you a baseline that ensures profitability. Even if you ultimately price higher based on value or market rates, knowing your cost floor prevents you from accidentally pricing below profitability. This is especially important when you’re negotiating or considering discounts.

Understand Your Cost Structure

Break down your costs:

• Identify direct costs that vary with each sale
• Allocate fixed costs appropriately across your products or services
• Calculate your break-even price using our Break-Even Calculator
• Determine the minimum price that covers all costs

Why this matters: Understanding your cost structure helps you make informed pricing decisions. If you know that your fixed costs are high, you might need higher prices or more volume to be profitable. If your variable costs are low, you have more flexibility to compete on price when necessary.

Pro tip: Use our Price Markup Calculator to calculate your baseline pricing. This gives you a solid foundation to build from, ensuring you never price below profitability. Then use our Break-Even Calculator to understand how many units you need to sell at different price points to cover your costs.

Step Two: Research Market Rates

Your costs tell you the minimum you can charge, but the market tells you what customers are willing to pay. Researching market rates helps you understand the price range customers expect, which prevents you from pricing too far outside market norms and losing sales unnecessarily.

Analyze Competitor Pricing

Study your competition:

• Research direct competitors who offer similar products or services
• Note the price range in your market, from lowest to highest
• Identify pricing tiers and what differentiates each tier
• Look for gaps in the market where you might position yourself

Why this matters: Competitor pricing provides context for your own pricing decisions. If you price significantly above competitors without clear differentiation, you’ll struggle to win customers. If you price significantly below, you might be leaving money on the table or signaling lower quality. Understanding the market range helps you position your prices appropriately.

Understand Value Positioning

See how value affects pricing:

• Identify competitors who charge premium prices and what justifies those prices
• Look for competitors who compete on price and what they sacrifice to do so
• Determine where your offering fits in the value spectrum
• Consider whether you should position at the high end, low end, or middle of the market

Why this matters: Market research isn’t just about matching competitor prices—it’s about understanding how value affects pricing in your market. If premium competitors charge 50% more but offer significantly more value, you can position yourself similarly if you provide comparable value. This understanding helps you price based on value rather than just matching competitors.

Pro tip: Create a competitive pricing matrix that shows competitor prices, their value propositions, and where you fit. This visual comparison helps you see pricing opportunities and position your offering appropriately. Don’t just copy competitor prices—use them as data points in your broader pricing strategy.

Step Three: Set Your Initial Price

With your cost baseline and market research complete, you’re ready to set your initial price. This price should fall somewhere between your cost floor and the top of the market range, positioned based on your value proposition and business goals.

Choose Your Price Point

Select from your options:

• Start with a price in the middle of the market range if you’re unsure
• Price toward the higher end if you have strong differentiation or premium positioning
• Price toward the lower end if you’re entering a competitive market or building initial traction
• Ensure your price is above your cost baseline to maintain profitability

Why this matters: Your initial price doesn’t have to be perfect—it just needs to be reasonable and profitable. Starting in the middle of the market range gives you room to adjust up or down based on customer response. The key is making a decision and testing it rather than delaying because you’re uncertain.

Document Your Pricing Rationale

Write down your reasoning:

• Note why you chose this specific price point
• Document your cost baseline and market research findings
• Explain how this price reflects your value proposition
• Set criteria for when you’ll reconsider this price

Why this matters: Documenting your pricing rationale helps you explain your prices to customers, team members, and investors. It also provides a reference point for future pricing decisions, so you can see what worked and what didn’t. This documentation is especially valuable when you need to justify price increases or defend your pricing strategy.

Pro tip: Set your initial price with the understanding that it’s a starting point, not a permanent decision. Choose a price that’s profitable, competitive, and aligned with your value proposition, then commit to testing it. The testing phase will reveal whether this price is optimal or needs adjustment.

Step Four: Test Your Price

Setting an initial price is just the beginning—you need to test it to see how customers actually respond. Testing helps you understand price sensitivity, identify optimal price points, and make data-driven adjustments rather than guessing.

Run Small Pricing Experiments

Test different approaches:

• Offer your product or service at the initial price and track sales volume
• Monitor customer feedback about pricing during sales conversations
• Track conversion rates at different price points if you’re testing multiple prices
• Measure how price affects customer acquisition and retention

Why this matters: Real customer behavior tells you more about optimal pricing than any calculation or market research. Customers might be willing to pay more than you thought, or they might be more price-sensitive than expected. Testing reveals these realities so you can adjust your pricing strategy accordingly.

Measure Price Impact

Track key metrics:

• Sales volume at your current price
• Customer acquisition cost relative to price
• Profit margin per sale
• Customer lifetime value at different price points
• Price-related objections in sales conversations

Why this matters: Measuring price impact helps you understand whether your current price is optimal. If sales volume is high but margins are low, you might be able to raise prices. If sales volume is low but margins are high, you might need to lower prices to increase volume. These metrics guide your pricing adjustments.

Pro tip: Test prices systematically rather than randomly changing them. Run tests for a specific period, measure results consistently, and compare outcomes. Use our Price Elasticity Calculator to understand how price changes affect demand, which helps you predict the impact of price adjustments.

Step Five: Iterate Based on Data

Pricing is an ongoing process, not a one-time decision. As you gather data from testing, you should iterate on your prices to optimize profitability, market position, and customer satisfaction. This iterative approach ensures your prices stay aligned with market conditions and business goals.

Analyze Test Results

Review what you learned:

• Compare sales volume, revenue, and profit at different price points
• Identify the price point that maximizes profitability
• Consider customer feedback about value and pricing
• Evaluate whether your initial price was too high, too low, or about right

Why this matters: Analysis turns test data into actionable insights. By comparing results across different price points, you can identify patterns and make informed decisions about optimal pricing. This analysis should consider not just revenue but also profitability, customer acquisition, and long-term value.

Make Informed Adjustments

Adjust based on evidence:

• Raise prices if customers accept them easily and sales volume remains strong
• Lower prices if sales volume is low and customers cite price as a barrier
• Test price increases gradually to avoid shocking existing customers
• Consider segmenting prices if different customer groups have different price sensitivity

Why this matters: Informed adjustments improve your pricing over time. Rather than making random changes, you’re responding to real data about customer behavior and market conditions. This approach builds pricing confidence because each adjustment is based on evidence rather than guesswork.

Continue Testing

Make testing ongoing:

• Regularly review pricing performance and market conditions
• Test price adjustments when costs change or market conditions shift
• Monitor competitor pricing changes and adjust accordingly
• Use pricing tests to validate major business decisions

Why this matters: Ongoing testing ensures your prices stay optimal as your business and market evolve. Costs change, competitors adjust prices, and customer preferences shift. Regular testing helps you stay ahead of these changes and maintain pricing that maximizes profitability.

Pro tip: Create a pricing review schedule—monthly, quarterly, or annually depending on your business—to ensure you’re regularly evaluating and optimizing your prices. Use our calculators to model different pricing scenarios and predict the impact of changes before you implement them.

Your Next Steps

Pricing confidence comes from having a systematic process, not from guessing correctly. Start by calculating your baseline, then work through each step methodically.

This Week:

1. Calculate your cost-based baseline using our Price Markup Calculator
2. Research competitor pricing to understand market rates
3. Set your initial price based on costs, market research, and value positioning
4. Document your pricing rationale for future reference

This Month:

1. Test your initial price by tracking sales volume and customer feedback
2. Measure price impact on sales, margins, and customer acquisition
3. Analyze test results to identify optimal price points
4. Make informed adjustments based on data

Going Forward:

1. Continue testing prices regularly as market conditions change
2. Use pricing data to inform business decisions and strategy
3. Build pricing confidence through systematic testing and iteration
4. Make pricing optimization a regular part of your business operations

Need help? Check out our Price Markup Calculator for cost-based pricing, our Break-Even Calculator for profitability analysis, our Price Elasticity Calculator for demand analysis, and our price elasticity guide for deeper understanding of customer price sensitivity.

Stay informed about business strategies and tools by following us on X (Twitter) and signing up for The Initiative Newsletter.

Tweet to @BisInitiative