From Spray-and-Pray to Precision: Building a Focused Acquisition Strategy

You’re trying every channel, hoping something works. You spread budget across many channels, but nothing performs well. This spray-and-pray approach wastes budget on ineffective channels while preventing focus on what works.

Focused acquisition strategy solves this by narrowing to proven channels. It concentrates budget on channels that work, which helps you improve efficiency and scale what’s proven. This focus is essential for efficient acquisition.

This guide provides a strategic approach to narrowing efforts to a few proven channels, helping you move from scattered acquisition to focused strategy.

We’ll explore why focus matters, how to identify winners, narrowing strategies, building focus, and scaling focused channels. By the end, you’ll understand how to build a focused acquisition strategy.

Why Focus Matters

Spray-and-pray wastes budget on ineffective channels. You spread money across many channels, but none perform well because you can’t optimize any of them. This scattering prevents focus and efficiency.

Focus matters because it enables optimization. When you concentrate budget on proven channels, you can optimize and scale them. This concentration improves efficiency and results.

The reality: Most businesses spread budget too thin across too many channels, which prevents optimization. Focused strategy concentrates on proven channels, which improves efficiency and results.

Identifying Winners

Winner identification finds channels that show promise. When you identify winners through testing and measurement, you can focus on what works.

Performance Metrics

Measure channel performance:

• Calculate CAC by channel
• Measure conversion rates
• Track customer quality
• Assess channel efficiency
• Identify top performers

Why this matters: Performance metrics show winners. If channels have low CAC and high conversion, they’re winners. This measurement helps you identify channels to focus on.

Consistency Indicators

Look for consistent performance:

• Channels that perform consistently
• Stable CAC over time
• Reliable conversion rates
• Predictable results
• Consistent winners

Why this matters: Consistency indicates reliability. If channels perform consistently, they’re reliable winners. This consistency helps you identify channels you can depend on.

Scalability Signals

Assess scaling potential:

• Channels that can scale
• Room to increase budget
• Potential for growth
• Scalable winners
• Channels worth focusing on

Why this matters: Scalability signals show potential. If channels can scale, they’re worth focusing on. This assessment helps you identify channels with growth potential.

Quality Indicators

Measure customer quality:

• Customer lifetime value by channel
• Retention rates by channel
• Customer satisfaction
• Quality winners
• Channels that attract good customers

Why this matters: Quality indicators show value. If channels attract high-quality customers, they’re winners. This measurement helps you identify channels that provide long-term value.

Pro tip: Use our Customer Acquisition Cost Calculator to measure channel performance. Calculate CAC for each channel and compare. Focus on channels with lowest CAC and highest customer quality. This measurement helps you identify winners.

Narrowing Strategies

Narrowing strategies help you focus on proven channels. When you narrow to winners, you improve efficiency and results.

Cut Bottom Performers

Eliminate worst channels:

• Identify channels with highest CAC
• Cut channels with lowest conversion
• Eliminate inconsistent performers
• Remove bottom performers
• Free budget for winners

Why this matters: Cutting bottom performers frees budget. If you eliminate worst channels, you free budget for winners. This cutting helps you focus on what works.

Consolidate Similar Channels

Combine related channels:

• Group similar channels together
• Focus on best in each category
• Consolidate to reduce complexity
• Simplify channel mix
• Focus on category winners

Why this matters: Consolidating reduces complexity. If you combine similar channels, you simplify and focus. This consolidation helps you build focused strategy.

Focus on Top 2-3

Narrow to proven winners:

• Identify top 2-3 channels
• Focus budget on these channels
• Eliminate or reduce others
• Build focus on winners
• Concentrate effort

Why this matters: Focusing on top 2-3 builds concentration. If you narrow to proven winners, you can optimize and scale them. This focus improves efficiency and results.

Gradual Narrowing

Reduce channels over time:

• Gradually reduce channel count
• Cut one channel at a time
• Monitor impact of reductions
• Narrow gradually
• Build focus incrementally

Why this matters: Gradual narrowing reduces risk. If you narrow gradually, you can monitor impact and adjust. This approach helps you build focus safely.

Building Focus

Building focus concentrates effort on proven channels. When you build focus, you optimize and scale what works.

Budget Concentration

Concentrate budget on winners:

• Allocate more budget to proven channels
• Reduce budget for other channels
• Focus spending on winners
• Maximize investment in proven
• Build budget focus

Why this matters: Budget concentration maximizes impact. If you concentrate budget on winners, you maximize results. This concentration helps you build focus effectively.

Effort Concentration

Focus team effort:

• Assign team to proven channels
• Focus optimization efforts
• Concentrate learning and improvement
• Build expertise in focused channels
• Maximize effort impact

Why this matters: Effort concentration improves results. If you focus team effort on proven channels, you improve performance. This concentration helps you build expertise and results.

Optimization Focus

Optimize focused channels:

• Deep optimization of proven channels
• Test and improve continuously
• Build expertise in channels
• Maximize channel performance
• Focus optimization efforts

Why this matters: Optimization focus improves performance. If you optimize focused channels deeply, you improve results. This focus helps you maximize channel value.

Learning Focus

Learn from focused channels:

• Deep understanding of proven channels
• Learn what works and why
• Build knowledge in focused channels
• Apply learnings to improve
• Focus learning efforts

Why this matters: Learning focus builds expertise. If you learn deeply about focused channels, you build expertise. This learning helps you improve performance over time.

Scaling Focused Channels

Scaling focused channels grows proven channels. When you scale what works, you maximize results from focused strategy.

Incremental Scaling

Scale gradually:

• Increase budget gradually
• Scale in increments
• Monitor performance as you scale
• Scale carefully
• Build scale safely

Why this matters: Incremental scaling reduces risk. If you scale gradually, you can monitor impact and adjust. This scaling helps you grow safely.

Performance Monitoring

Track performance as you scale:

• Monitor CAC as budget increases
• Track conversion rates
• Measure customer quality
• Ensure performance maintained
• Monitor scaling impact

Why this matters: Performance monitoring ensures quality. If you monitor performance as you scale, you can ensure quality maintained. This monitoring helps you scale effectively.

Optimization While Scaling

Continue optimizing:

• Optimize as you scale
• Test improvements continuously
• Improve performance while growing
• Maintain optimization focus
• Scale and optimize together

Why this matters: Optimization while scaling improves results. If you optimize as you scale, you improve performance. This optimization helps you maximize scaling value.

Scaling Limits

Know when to stop scaling:

• Identify scaling limits
• Recognize when efficiency declines
• Stop scaling when performance drops
• Maintain efficiency
• Scale within limits

Why this matters: Scaling limits prevent waste. If you know when to stop scaling, you prevent efficiency decline. This awareness helps you scale effectively.

Pro tip: Scale focused channels by 20-30% at a time and monitor performance. If CAC stays low and quality maintained, scale more. If performance declines, stop scaling and optimize. This approach helps you scale safely and effectively.

Your Next Steps

Focused acquisition strategy improves efficiency. Identify winning channels, narrow to proven ones, build focus, then scale what works to maximize results.

This Week:

1. Calculate CAC and measure performance for all channels
2. Identify top 2-3 performing channels
3. Assess which channels to cut or reduce
4. Plan budget reallocation to winners

This Month:

1. Cut or reduce bottom-performing channels
2. Concentrate budget on top 2-3 channels
3. Focus optimization efforts on proven channels
4. Monitor performance of focused strategy

Going Forward:

1. Maintain focus on proven channels
2. Scale focused channels incrementally
3. Continue optimizing focused channels
4. Resist temptation to add new untested channels

Need help? Check out our Customer Acquisition Cost Calculator for measuring channel performance, our CAC calculation guide for accurate measurement, our channel fit guide for choosing channels, and our channel scaling guide for growing proven channels.

Stay informed about business strategies and tools by following us on X (Twitter) and signing up for The Initiative Newsletter.

Tweet to @BisInitiative