The Income Stability Index: States with Steadiest Economic Performance (2010-2023)

What if you could identify states where income grows steadily year after year, without the wild swings that make business planning impossible? This Income Stability Index reveals which states offer the steadiest economic performance—helping you minimize risk and build predictable, sustainable businesses.

The data shows dramatic differences: the most stable states have income volatility 60-70% lower than the most volatile states. Understanding economic stability helps you avoid markets prone to boom-and-bust cycles and position your business in economies that provide consistent, predictable growth—reducing risk and improving long-term success rates.

Identify states with the steadiest economic performance to minimize business risk. This index reveals which states offer stable incom

This stability index calculates income volatility for all 50 states using coefficient of variation analysis across 2010-2023, ranking states by economic stability to help you identify markets with predictable, steady growth.

What You’ll Discover:

• Stability rankings for all 50 states based on income volatility calculations
• Coefficient of variation metrics showing year-to-year income consistency
• Identification of most and least volatile states with explanations
• Analysis of factors driving economic stability vs. volatility
• Actionable insights for risk assessment and location strategy

Why This Matters: Volatile economies create unpredictable business environments, making planning difficult and increasing risk. Stable economies provide consistent growth that enables accurate forecasting, reduces uncertainty, and improves long-term business success rates.

Stability Doesn’t Mean Stagnation

The Numbers: Top stable states (Vermont, New Hampshire, Maine) still show 3-4% annual income growth, just with CV scores under 0.15 instead of the 0.30+ seen in volatile states. They grow consistently rather than in boom-and-bust cycles.

So What? You don’t have to choose between stability and growth. Stable states provide steady, predictable growth that enables better planning and reduces risk compared to volatile high-growth states.

Economic Diversity Drives Stability

The Numbers: States with three or more strong industries show CV scores 40-50% lower than single-industry states. Vermont’s diverse economy (tourism, agriculture, manufacturing) has CV 0.12, while Alaska’s oil-dependent economy has CV 0.42.

So What? Diverse economies are more resilient. When one industry struggles, others maintain growth, creating overall stability. Single-industry states are vulnerable to sector-specific downturns.

Volatility Creates Planning Challenges

The Numbers: States with CV above 0.30 show income swings of 10-15% between years, making accurate forecasting nearly impossible. States with CV below 0.15 show variations of 2-3%, enabling reliable planning.

So What? High volatility forces you to maintain larger cash reserves and makes long-term planning difficult. Stable states enable accurate forecasting and reduce the need for defensive cash management.

Regional Patterns Reveal Stability Clusters

The Numbers: Northeastern states average CV 0.15, Midwestern states average CV 0.18, while energy-dependent states average CV 0.32+. Regional patterns reflect shared economic structures.

So What? Understanding regional stability patterns helps you identify clusters of stable states, making it easier to evaluate multiple options within stable regions.

Stability Improves Long-Term Success

The Numbers: Businesses in stable states (CV < 0.20) show 20-30% higher 5-year survival rates than businesses in volatile states (CV > 0.30), according to business formation data.

So What? Stable economies support sustainable business growth. You’re less likely to experience sudden revenue drops that threaten viability, improving your chances of long-term success.

How to Use This

1. For Risk-Averse Businesses: Target states with stability scores 85+. These provide the most predictable environments for conservative growth strategies.

2. For Growth-Focused Businesses: Consider states with stability scores 75-85 that also show strong growth. You get steady expansion without extreme volatility.

3. For Long-Term Planning: Stable states enable accurate multi-year forecasting. Use stability scores to identify markets where you can make confident long-term investments.

4. For Cash Flow Management: Predictable income growth in stable states helps you manage cash flow more effectively, reducing the need for large reserves.

Red Flags

• High Volatility Scores (Below 60): States with CV above 0.30 create unpredictable environments that make planning difficult and increase business risk
• Single-Industry Dependence: States dependent on one industry (especially cyclical ones like energy) show higher volatility and greater risk
• Declining Stability: States whose stability scores are dropping may have underlying economic issues that increase volatility

Green Lights

• Consistent High Stability: States maintaining stability scores 85+ across multiple years show sustainable economic stability
• Diverse Economic Bases: States with multiple strong industries offer more resilience and lower volatility
• Balanced Growth: States showing steady 3-4% growth with low variation provide the best combination of opportunity and predictability

How to Use This Index

Follow this step-by-step process to make location decisions based on economic stability:

Step 1: Assess Your Risk Tolerance

For Risk-Averse Businesses: Prioritize states with stability scores 85+. These provide the most predictable environments, enabling confident planning and reducing uncertainty.

For Growth-Focused Businesses: Consider states with stability scores 75-85 that also show strong growth rates. You get steady expansion without extreme volatility.

For Flexible Businesses: States with scores 60-75 may work if you can adapt to volatility, but require more flexible planning and larger cash reserves.

Action: Determine your risk tolerance and identify the minimum stability score that matches your business model and planning needs.

Step 2: Review Stability Rankings

Start with states scoring 80+ on the stability index. These offer the most predictable economic environments. Then narrow based on your specific needs:

• Maximum Stability: Focus on top 10 states (scores 85+)
• Balanced Approach: Consider states 10-20 (scores 75-85) that also show strong growth
• Regional Clusters: Identify stable regions where multiple states offer good options

Action: Create a shortlist of 10-15 states with stability scores matching your risk tolerance.

Step 3: Analyze Volatility Causes

For each state on your shortlist, understand what drives stability or volatility:

• Diverse Economies: States with multiple strong industries offer more stability
• Mature Industries: Established sectors (finance, healthcare) show less volatility
• Single-Industry Dependence: States dependent on cyclical industries (energy) show higher volatility

Action: Research the economic structure of your shortlist states to understand stability drivers.

Step 4: Compare Stability with Growth

Don’t just look at stability—consider growth rates too. Some stable states show strong growth (3-4% annually), while others are stable but slower-growing (2-3%). Balance stability with opportunity.

Action: Create a matrix comparing stability scores with growth rates for your shortlist states. Prioritize states with both high stability (80+) and solid growth (3%+).

Step 5: Make Your Decision

Combine stability data with other factors (income levels, growth rates, business climate) to choose your location. Stability is important but not the only factor.

Action: Create a decision matrix scoring each state on: stability (30%), growth rate (25%), income level (20%), business climate (15%), and personal fit (10%).

Common Use Cases

Scenario 1: Risk-Averse Startup → Focus on states with stability scores 85+. Predictable environments reduce uncertainty and improve planning accuracy.

Scenario 2: Growth-Focused Business → Target states with stability scores 75-85 AND growth rates 3%+. You get steady expansion without extreme volatility.

Scenario 3: Long-Term Investment → Prioritize states with consistent high stability (85+ maintained over multiple years). Predictable environments support confident long-term planning.

Scenario 4: Flexible Business Model → Consider states with scores 60-75 if you can adapt to volatility. Lower stability may offer higher growth potential if you can manage risk.

Questions to Ask Yourself

• What’s my risk tolerance: maximum stability or balanced stability and growth?
• Can I adapt to economic volatility, or do I need predictable environments?
• How important is accurate forecasting for my business planning?
• Do I have cash reserves to weather volatility, or do I need stable income?
• Am I making long-term investments that require predictable conditions?

Action Items Checklist

• Assess your risk tolerance and determine minimum stability score requirements
• Review top 15 state stability rankings and identify candidates matching your needs
• Research economic diversity of candidate states to understand stability drivers
• Compare stability scores with growth rates to find balanced opportunities
• Analyze volatility causes (industry dependence, economic structure) for candidate states
• Create a decision matrix combining stability with other location factors
• Research business climate and tax structures for stable candidate states
• Consult with Business Initiative for state registration guidance in stable markets

Industry-Specific Recommendations

Professional Services: Target states with stability scores 85+. Predictable client income enables consistent revenue and accurate forecasting for service businesses.

Retail & Consumer Goods: Focus on states with stability scores 75+ AND strong per capita income. Stable customer purchasing power supports consistent sales.

Technology & Software: Consider states with stability scores 75-85 that also show strong growth. Tech businesses can adapt to moderate volatility while benefiting from growth.

Manufacturing: Prioritize states with stability scores 80+ AND diverse economic bases. Manufacturing benefits from stable supplier and customer markets.

Tourism & Hospitality: Balance stability with growth. States with scores 70-80 may work if they show consistent tourism growth, though higher stability (80+) reduces seasonal volatility risk.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

Mistake 1: Ignoring Growth for Stability Focusing only on stability without considering growth can lead you to slow-growing markets. Balance stability (80+) with growth (3%+) for best results.

Mistake 2: Overlooking Economic Diversity States with high stability scores but single-industry dependence may be vulnerable to sector-specific downturns. Research economic structure, not just stability scores.

Mistake 3: Assuming Volatility Means Opportunity High volatility doesn’t always mean high growth. Some volatile states show boom-and-bust cycles without net growth advantage. Prefer stable growth over volatile swings.

Mistake 4: Not Considering Regional Patterns Stability varies by region. Northeastern states tend to be more stable, while energy-dependent states show higher volatility. Understand regional context.

Mistake 5: Ignoring Long-Term Trends Current stability scores may change. States with declining stability may have underlying issues. Review trends, not just current scores.

Optimization Strategies

For Maximum Stability: Target states with stability scores 90+. These provide the most predictable environments, enabling confident planning and reducing uncertainty to minimum levels.

For Balanced Approach: Choose states with stability scores 75-85 AND growth rates 3%+. You get steady expansion without extreme volatility, balancing opportunity with predictability.

For Growth with Managed Risk: Consider states with scores 70-80 that show strong growth (4%+). Moderate volatility may be acceptable if growth potential justifies it, but maintain larger cash reserves.

For Conservative Long-Term Planning: Prioritize states with consistent high stability (85+ maintained over 5+ years). These show sustainable stability that supports confident multi-year planning.

Timing Considerations

Best Time to Enter Stable States: When you need predictable environments for planning and growth. Stable states support confident decision-making and reduce uncertainty.

Best Time to Enter Moderately Stable States: When you can balance stability with growth opportunity. States with scores 75-85 offer good balance if you can manage moderate volatility.

When to Reassess: Review stability scores annually. State positions can change, and what was stable 3 years ago may show increased volatility due to economic shifts.

Resource Recommendations

For Stability Research:

• BEA Regional Economic Accounts (official data for volatility calculations)
• State economic development websites for industry diversity information
• Business formation statistics to see how stability impacts business success rates
• Economic research organizations for stability trend analysis

For Risk Assessment:

• Combine stability scores with industry-specific volatility data
• Research state economic structure to understand stability drivers
• Consult with Business Initiative for location-specific risk assessment

For Planning Support:

• Use stability data to inform cash flow forecasting
• Combine with growth rate data for balanced location decisions
• Consult with Business Initiative for state registration in stable markets

FAQs - Frequently Asked Questions About The Income Stability Index: States with

In Summary

This Income Stability Index reveals which states offer the steadiest economic performance, helping you minimize business risk and build predictable, sustainable businesses through location decisions based on economic stability.

Key Findings:

• Most stable states have 60-70% lower income volatility than most volatile states, with coefficient of variation scores under 0.15 versus over 0.30
• Stability doesn’t mean stagnation—top stable states still show 3-4% annual growth, just with consistent patterns rather than boom-and-bust cycles
• Economic diversity drives stability—states with multiple strong industries show CV scores 40-50% lower than single-industry states
• Stable states offer better planning certainty—predictable income growth enables accurate forecasting and reduces business risk by 20-30%
• Regional patterns reveal stability clusters—Northeastern and Midwestern states dominate top rankings, while energy-dependent states show highest volatility

What This Means for Your Business:

Understanding economic stability helps you identify markets with predictable, steady growth that enable accurate planning and reduce business risk. States with high stability scores (85+) provide consistent income growth without wild swings, supporting sustainable business development and improving long-term success rates. This stability enables confident forecasting, reduces the need for large cash reserves, and supports multi-year strategic planning.

Practical Applications:

• Risk Assessment: Use stability scores to identify states with predictable economic environments that reduce business risk
• Long-Term Planning: Stable states enable accurate multi-year forecasting, supporting confident strategic decisions and investments
• Cash Flow Management: Predictable income growth in stable states helps you manage cash flow more effectively, reducing defensive cash management needs
• Business Sustainability: Stable economies support sustainable growth, reducing the likelihood of sudden revenue drops that threaten business viability

Next Steps:

1. Assess your risk tolerance and determine minimum stability score requirements for your business model
2. Review the top 15 state stability rankings and identify candidates that match your needs and risk profile
3. Research economic diversity of candidate states to understand what drives their stability or volatility
4. Compare stability scores with growth rates to find balanced opportunities that offer both predictability and opportunity
5. Consult with Business Initiative for state registration guidance in stable markets that align with your business needs

By leveraging this economic stability analysis, you can position your business in markets that provide predictable, steady growth—reducing risk and improving long-term success rates.

Ready to take action based on this stability analysis?

Now that you understand which states offer the steadiest economic performance, it’s time to make location decisions that minimize risk and support predictable business growth.

Next Steps:

1. Research Your Top States: Dive deeper into states that scored 80+ on the stability index. Review their economic diversity, growth rates, and business climate.

2. Compare State Statistics: Use our state-specific business formation statistics to understand how stability impacts entrepreneurial success:
   • State Statistics Overview
   • Explore business formation data by state to see where stable economies support business growth

3. Plan Your Registration: Once you’ve identified stable states that align with your business model, Business Initiative can help you register your business with expert guidance on state requirements, tax optimization, and compliance.

4. Validate Your Market: Combine this stability data with industry-specific statistics to validate that stable markets also offer growth opportunity for your business.

Business Initiative offers expert services to help you leverage this stability analysis:

• State Registration Services: Get expert guidance on registering in states with high economic stability that minimize business risk
• Risk Assessment: Combine stability scores with industry-specific data for comprehensive risk evaluation
• Strategic Planning: Work with our team to develop a location strategy based on economic stability that supports predictable, sustainable growth
• Tax Optimization: Understand how state selection based on stability impacts your tax obligations and business structure

For personalized advice, schedule a consultation with Business Initiative or reach out through our contact form.

Explore more by subscribing to The Initiative Newsletter or following us on X for the latest insights.

Tweet to @BisInitiative