Your marketing is scattered—trying social media, content, ads, events, but nothing works consistently. Random acts of marketing waste resources and produce poor results. A coherent acquisition strategy focuses on what works and eliminates what doesn’t.
WARNING: Scattered marketing efforts waste resources and produce poor results. Trying everything means excelling at nothing. A coherent strategy focuses efforts and improves results.
This article shows you how to build a coherent acquisition strategy.
Key Takeaways
- Focus on what works: Identify channels and tactics that actually produce results
- Eliminate what doesn't: Stop wasting resources on ineffective tactics
- Align with ICPs: Focus on channels and tactics that reach your ideal customers
- Create systems: Build repeatable processes for acquisition
- Measure and optimize: Track what works and double down on it
Table of Contents
Problems with Random Marketing
What Is Random Marketing?
- Trying many tactics without strategy
- No focus or coherence
- Scattered efforts
- No measurement or optimization
Problems:
- Wastes resources
- Poor results
- Can’t scale what works
- No learning
- Inefficient
Signs of Random Marketing:
- Trying many channels
- No clear strategy
- Can’t explain why you’re doing things
- Results are inconsistent
- Resources spread thin
What Is a Coherent Strategy?
Coherent Strategy Elements:
- Clear focus on what works
- Aligned with ideal customer profiles
- Systematic approach
- Measurable and optimized
- Scalable
Benefits:
- Better results
- More efficient
- Easier to scale
- Learn and improve
- Sustainable
Key Point: Coherent strategy focuses on what works and eliminates what doesn’t. It’s systematic, not random.
Audit Current Marketing
Step 1: List All Marketing Activities
- All channels you’re using
- All tactics you’re trying
- All campaigns
- Everything you’re doing
Step 2: Measure Results
- Leads generated
- Customers acquired
- Cost per lead/customer
- ROI for each activity
Step 3: Assess Alignment
- Do activities reach ICPs?
- Are they effective?
- Do they fit strategy?
- Are they scalable?
Step 4: Identify Patterns
- What’s working?
- What’s not?
- What patterns do you see?
- What can you learn?
Identify What Works
Criteria for “What Works”:
- Generates quality leads
- Reaches ICPs
- Cost-effective
- Scalable
- Consistent results
How to Identify:
- Look at data (leads, customers, cost)
- Compare results across activities
- Identify top performers
- Focus on what works
Examples:
- Channel A: 100 leads/month, $50/lead, 10% convert
- Channel B: 20 leads/month, $200/lead, 5% convert
- Channel A works better
Key Point: Identify what actually works based on data, not assumptions.
Eliminate What Doesn’t
Criteria for Elimination:
- Not generating results
- Not reaching ICPs
- Too expensive
- Not scalable
- Inconsistent results
How to Eliminate:
- Stop ineffective activities
- Reallocate resources to what works
- Don’t keep doing what doesn’t work
- Focus on winners
Decision Framework:
- If it’s not working, stop it
- If it’s too expensive, stop it
- If it doesn’t reach ICPs, stop it
- Focus resources on what works
Key Point: Eliminate what doesn’t work. Stop wasting resources on ineffective tactics.
Building Coherent Strategy
Step 1: Focus on Winners
- Identify 2-3 channels/tactics that work
- Focus resources on these
- Don’t try everything
- Excel at what works
Step 2: Align with ICPs
- Ensure channels reach ICPs
- Tailor messaging to ICPs
- Focus on ICP acquisition
- Don’t waste on wrong customers
Step 3: Create Systems
- Build repeatable processes
- Document what works
- Create playbooks
- Enable scaling
Step 4: Measure and Optimize
- Track results
- Measure what matters
- Optimize based on data
- Double down on winners
Step 5: Scale What Works
- Increase investment in winners
- Expand successful tactics
- Replicate success
- Grow systematically
Implementation
Phase 1: Audit (Week 1)
- Audit current marketing
- Measure results
- Identify what works
- Identify what doesn’t
Phase 2: Focus (Week 2)
- Eliminate what doesn’t work
- Focus on 2-3 winners
- Reallocate resources
- Stop random activities
Phase 3: Systematize (Weeks 3-4)
- Create systems for winners
- Document processes
- Build playbooks
- Enable scaling
Phase 4: Optimize (Ongoing)
- Track results
- Measure performance
- Optimize based on data
- Scale what works
Tools
Use these tools to build coherent strategy:
Analytics:
- Marketing analytics
- CRM data
- Conversion tracking
- ROI measurement
Planning:
- Strategy frameworks
- Channel planning
- Budget allocation
- Goal setting
Execution:
- Marketing automation
- Content management
- Campaign management
- Performance tracking
Risks
- Over-focusing: Don’t focus on too few channels. Need some diversification.
- Not testing: Don’t eliminate without testing. Test before eliminating.
- Not measuring: Can’t identify what works without measurement. Track results.
- Not optimizing: Strategy needs optimization. Don’t set and forget.
Recap
- Focus on what works: Identify channels and tactics that actually produce results
- Eliminate what doesn’t: Stop wasting resources on ineffective tactics
- Align with ICPs: Focus on channels and tactics that reach your ideal customers
- Create systems: Build repeatable processes for acquisition
- Measure and optimize: Track what works and double down on it
- Scale systematically: Grow what works, don’t try everything
Next Steps
- Audit all current marketing activities and measure results
- Identify what’s working (leads, customers, cost, ROI)
- Eliminate what’s not working (stop ineffective activities)
- Focus on 2-3 winning channels/tactics
- Create systems and processes for winners
- Measure and optimize based on results
- Scale what works systematically
With a coherent acquisition strategy, you focus marketing efforts on what works, eliminate waste, and build scalable systems that produce consistent results.
FAQs - Frequently Asked Questions About From Random Acts of Marketing to a Coherent Acquisition Strategy
What are the signs that your marketing is 'random acts' instead of a coherent strategy?
You're trying many channels without clear reasons, results are inconsistent, you can't explain why you're doing specific tactics, and your resources are spread thin.
Learn More...
The article identifies five clear signs of random marketing: you're trying many channels simultaneously, there's no clear strategy connecting your efforts, you can't articulate why you're using specific tactics, results are inconsistent across activities, and your resources are spread so thin that nothing gets enough attention to succeed.
The core problem is that random marketing wastes resources and produces poor results because trying everything means excelling at nothing. Without focus, you can't scale what works or learn from what doesn't.
How do you audit your current marketing to identify what's actually working?
List every marketing activity, measure leads generated and cost per customer for each, assess whether each reaches your ideal customers, and identify the top performers by data.
Learn More...
The audit follows four steps: first, list every channel, tactic, and campaign you're currently running. Second, measure concrete results—leads generated, customers acquired, cost per lead, and ROI for each activity. Third, assess alignment by checking whether activities actually reach your ideal customer profiles and are scalable. Fourth, identify patterns to see which activities consistently perform.
For example, if Channel A generates 100 leads per month at $50 each with a 10% conversion rate, while Channel B generates 20 leads at $200 each with a 5% conversion rate, the data clearly shows Channel A is the winner—something you can't see without measurement.
How many marketing channels should you focus on after eliminating what doesn't work?
Focus on 2-3 channels or tactics that your data shows consistently produce quality leads cost-effectively.
Learn More...
The article recommends narrowing to 2-3 winning channels or tactics based on your audit data. These should be the activities that generate quality leads, reach your ideal customer profiles, are cost-effective, and show consistent results.
By concentrating resources on just a few proven channels, you can invest enough to excel at them and build repeatable systems. The article warns against over-focusing on too few channels—you still need some diversification—but the shift from scattered to focused is what transforms random marketing into a coherent strategy.
What does the implementation timeline look like for building a coherent acquisition strategy?
Four phases: audit current marketing in week one, eliminate and focus in week two, systematize winners in weeks three and four, then optimize ongoing.
Learn More...
The article lays out a four-phase timeline. Phase 1 (Week 1): audit all marketing activities, measure results, and identify what works versus what doesn't. Phase 2 (Week 2): eliminate underperformers, focus on 2-3 winners, reallocate budget and resources. Phase 3 (Weeks 3-4): create repeatable systems and playbooks for your winning channels. Phase 4 (Ongoing): track results, measure performance, optimize based on data, and scale what works.
This means you can shift from scattered to strategic in under a month, with continuous improvement from that point forward.
How do you align marketing efforts with your ideal customer profiles during this transition?
Ensure every channel you keep actually reaches your ICPs, tailor messaging specifically to them, and stop spending on channels that attract the wrong audience.
Learn More...
ICP alignment is central to the coherent strategy. After identifying winning channels, verify that each one reaches the customers you actually want—not just any leads, but the right leads. Tailor your messaging to speak directly to their needs and pain points.
Channels that generate leads but not from your ideal customers should be eliminated even if the volume looks good. The article frames this as a quality filter: don't just measure leads and cost, but whether the leads match your ideal customer profile and can actually become profitable customers.
What are the risks of narrowing your marketing focus too aggressively?
Over-focusing on too few channels leaves you vulnerable if one fails, and eliminating tactics without proper testing may cut something that could have worked.
Learn More...
The article identifies four risks: over-focusing on too few channels without any diversification, eliminating tactics before properly testing them, not measuring results so you can't distinguish winners from losers, and setting a strategy but never optimizing it.
The key safeguard is to test before eliminating and maintain enough channel diversity that you're not completely dependent on one source. A coherent strategy isn't about putting all your eggs in one basket—it's about concentrating resources on proven winners while keeping the door open for calculated experiments.